Asia-Pacific Forum on Science Learning and Teaching, Volume 19, Issue 2, Article 11 (Dec., 2018) |
Table 1, Table 2, and Table 3 present the descriptive statistics related to the students' knowledge on the symbol, unit, and formula of the fundamental physical quantities. The data obtained from the data sheet are generally indicated that the students do not comprehend the symbol, unit, and formula of the fundamental physical quantities by solving problems concerning classical mechanics, and electricity and magnetism. The results of the research are presented as follows:
- Roughly 20% of the students answered the symbol and unit of the mass density while 50% of the students could not respond the symbol and unit of mass density.
- Almost 15% of the students defined the symbol and unit of the pressure. 80% of the students could not write the formula of the pressure.
- 80% of the students determined the symbol and unit of the force. Approximately 45% of the students could not write the formula of the force based on Newton's Laws of Motion.
- Roughly 65% of the students could not give any answer the symbol and unit of the torque.
- Approximately 60% of the students did not describe the symbol and unit of the weight.
- 50% of students indicated the symbol and unit of the velocity and acceleration.
- Approximately 85% of the students could not define the symbol, unit and formula of the angular velocity and the angular acceleration.
- Almost 30% of the students identified the symbol and unit of the work. 70% of the students could not write the formula of the work.
- Roughly 70% of the students could not indicate the symbol, unit, and formula of the heat.
- 20% of the students showed the symbol and unit of the power while 70% of the students could not write the formula of the power.
- Approximately 70% of the students could not describe the symbol, unit, and formula of the impulse.
- Nearly 80% of the students could not determine the symbol, unit, and formula of the momentum.
- Almost all students did not determine the symbol, unit, and formula of the angular momentum.
- Roughly 75% of the students responded the symbol, unit, and formula of the electric field strength.
- Nearly 90% of the students could not determine the symbol, unit, and formula of the electric flux and electric flux density.
- Many students described the symbol, unit, and formula of the electric potential, capacitance, electric current, and resistance.
- Almost 50% of the students could not determine the symbol, unit, and formula of the current density.
- Nearly 25% of the students described the symbol and unit of the magnetic flux density while 90% of the students could not write the formula of the magnetic flux density.
- Roughly 70% of the students could not define the symbol, unit, and formula of the magnetic flux.
- Many students did not determine the symbol, unit, and formula of the magnetic dipole moment, magnetization, and inductance.
Table 1: The Descriptive Analysis of Student Responses Related to Some Fundamental Physical Quantities' Symbol and Name for Physics I
Physical Quantities
SI Derived Units
Correct
Incorrect
No Answer
Quantity
NameQuantity Symbol*
Name in SI
Symbol in SI
N
%
N
%
N
%
Mass Density
ρ
kilogram per cubic meter
kg/m3
51
23.2
55
25.0
114
51.8
Pressure
P
pascal
Pa
37
16.8
58
26.6
125
56.8
Force
F
newton
N
171
77.7
2
0.9
47
21.4
Torque
τ
newton meter
Nm
47
21.4
27
12.3
146
66.4
Weight
W
kilogram meter per second squared
N
61
27.7
31
14.1
128
58.2
Velocity
v
meter per second
m/s
116
52.7
22
10.0
82
37.3
Acceleration
a
meter per second squared
m/s2
120
54.5
10
4.5
90
40.9
Angular Velocity
ω
radian per second
rad/s
16
7.3
21
9.5
183
83.2
Angular Acceleration
α
radian per second squared
rad/s2
11
5.0
18
8.1
191
86.8
Work
W
joule
J
68
30.9
49
22.3
103
46.8
Heat
Q
joule
J
47
21.4
16
7.3
157
71.4
Power
P
watt
W
43
19.5
64
29.1
113
51.4
Impulse
I
newton second
Ns
20
9.1
55
25.0
145
65.9
Momentum
p
kilogram meter per second
kgm/s
10
4.5
37
16.8
173
78.6
Angular Momentum
L
kilogram meter squared per second
kgm2/s
0
0
11
5.0
209
95.0
Note: *The vectors are indicated in bold. 15 fundamental physical quantities were selected for Physics I.
Table 2: The Descriptive Analysis of Student Responses Related to Some Fundamental Physical Quantities' Symbol and Name for Physics II
Physical Quantities
SI Derived Units
Correct
Incorrect
No Answer
Quantity
NameQuantity Symbol*
Name in SI
Symbol in SI
N
%
N
%
N
%
Electric Field Strength
E
volt per meter
V/m
167
75.9
14
6.36
39
17.7
Electric Flux
φ
newton square meter per coulumb
Nm2/C
7
3.18
13
5.91
200
90.1
Electric Flux Density
D
coulomb per square meter
C/A2
0
0
9
4.1
211
95.9
Electric Potential
V
volt
V
163
74.1
7
3.18
50
22.7
Capacitance
C
farad
F
175
79.5
20
9.1
25
11.3
Electric Current
I
ampere
A
180
81.8
29
13.1
11
5.0
Current Density
J
ampere per square meter
A/m2
83
37.7
18
8.18
119
54.1
Resistance
R
ohm
Ω
166
75.4
9
4.1
45
20.4
Magnetic Flux Density
B
tesla
T
52
23.6
23
10.4
145
65.9
Magnetic Flux
Φm
weber
Wb
35
15.9
24
10.9
161
73.1
Magnetic Dipole Moment
μ
ampere per square meter
A/m2
3
1.36
18
8.18
199
90.4
Magnetization
M
ampere per meter
A/m
2
0.9
13
5.91
205
93.1
Inductance
L
henry
H
11
5.0
7
3.18
202
91.8
Note: *The vectors are indicated in bold. 13 fundamental physical quantities were selected for Physics II.
SI units are divided into base and derived units. Base units consist of the meter, the kilogram, the second, the ampere, the kelvin, the mole, and the candela (Taylor & Thompson, 2008). Derived units "are formed as products of powers of the base units according to the algebraic relations linking the quantities concerned" (Taylor, 2001, p. 3).
Table 3: The Descriptive Analysis of Student Responses Related to Some Fundamental Physical Quantities' Formula and Name for Physics I and II
Some Derived Fundamental Physical Quantity
Correct
Incorrect
No Answer
Quantity Name
Formula*
N
%
N
%
N
%
Mass Density
ρ = m/V
67
30.5
42
19.1
111
50.5
Pressure
P = F/A
23
10.4
21
9.5
176
80.0
Force
F = ma
84
38.2
34
15.5
102
46.4
Torque
τ = Fd
83
37.7
40
18.2
97
44.1
Weight
W = mg
83
37.7
57
25.9
80
36.4
Velocity
v = Δx/Δt
87
39.5
9
4.1
124
56.4
Acceleration
a= Δv/Δt
87
39.5
10
4.5
123
55.9
Angular Velocity
ω = dθ/dt
18
8.2
14
6.4
188
85.5
Angular Acceleration
α = d2θ/dt2
13
5.9
17
7.7
190
86.3
Work
W = Fx Δx
48
21.8
12
5.5
160
72.7
Heat
Q = mcΔT
31
14.1
22
10.0
167
75.9
Power
P = W/t
39
17.7
27
12.3
154
70.0
Impulse
I = FΔt
41
18.6
18
8.2
161
73.2
Momentum
p = mv
20
9.1
21
9.5
179
81.4
Angular Momentum
L = Iω
0
0
0
0
220
100
Electric Field Strength
E = F/q
174
79.1
17
7.72
29
13.3
Electric Flux
3
1.36
19
8.63
198
90
Electric Flux Density
D = εE
0
0
9
4.1
211
95.9
Electric Potential
V = kq/r
161
73.1
13
5.9
46
20.9
Capacitance
C = q/V
168
76.3
14
6.3
38
17.2
Electric Current
I= ΔQ/Δt
189
85.9
17
7.72
14
6.36
Current Density
J = I/A
92
41.8
23
10.4
105
47.7
Resistance
R = V/I
173
78.6
11
5.0
36
16.3
Magnetic Flux Density
B = μH
5
2.27
15
6.81
200
90.1
Magnetic Flux
46
20.9
17
7.72
157
71.3
Magnetic Dipole Moment
0
0
24
10.9
196
89.1
Magnetization
M = dμ/dV
2
0.9
15
6.81
203
92.2
Inductance
L = Φm
2
0.9
12
5.45
206
93.6
* The vectors are indicated in bold. The book of Tipler & Mosca (2008) was used for the formula of fundamental physical quantities.
Table 4 shows cognitive and affective opinion of the students on the symbol, unit, and formula of the fundamental physical quantities. The cognitive and affective opinion of the students were generally evaluated respectively, approximately 85% of the students thought in terms of the cognitive opinion of the students that the usage of symbol, unit, and formula of the fundamental physical quantities was not useful to solve quantitative and qualitative problems. The essential keys of the fundamental physical quantities did not help to enhance their problem solving skills. Besides they did not make an effort to learn the relationships between symbol and unit, and formula of the fundamental physical quantities. Many students believed in terms of the affective opinion of the students that the usage of the essential keys of the fundamental physical quantities was a waste of time, they did not want to solve the problems by using the essential keys, besides the essential keys do not make sense to learn the students.
Table 4. The cognitive and affective opinion of the students on the symbol, unit, and formula (S/U/F) of some fundamental physical quantities
Positive
Negative
Cognitive Opinion
N
%
N
%
It provides hints for problem solving.
8
26.67
22
73.33
It helps to connect among parameters.
4
13.33
26
86.67
It helps to recall the formula.
5
16.67
25
83.33
It facilitates to understand the physical concepts.
6
20.00
24
80.00
It makes a sense.
4
13.33
26
86.67
It helps to solve problems.
5
16.67
25
83.33
It helps to enhance problem solving skills.
3
10.00
27
90.00
Affective Opinion
Students enjoy performing mathematical operations.
2
6.67
28
93.33
Students take pleasure in problem solving.
2
6.67
28
93.33
Students are interested in problem solving.
3
10.00
27
90.00
Students get bored with the usage of the essential keys.
26
86.67
4
13.33
Students use the essential keys in their daily lives.
2
6.67
28
93.33
Students like to deal with the essential keys.
2
6.67
28
93.33
Students feel comfortable with the usage of the essential keys.
4
13.33
26
86.67
Students think that the usage of the essential keys is a waste of time.
28
93.33
2
6.67
Students think that the usage of the essential keys is entertaining.
4
13.33
26
86.67
Copyright (C) 2018 EdUHK APFSLT. Volume 19, Issue 2, Article 11 (Dec., 2018). All Rights Reserved.